Jdsk wrote: ↑27 Mar 2024, 2:44pm
Psamathe wrote: ↑27 Mar 2024, 2:38pm
With the health aspects of exercise one wonders if an increasingly stretched NHS might start to focus more on exercise as a treatment.
It gets very complex involving health policy, balancing budgets, treatment availability, moral case, NHS charter, etc. most way beyond my knowledge.
But behaviour aspects do (or at least did) affect the treatments you could be offered under the NHS. As I understand it, if you drink excessively then you wont be considered for a liver transplant until you get your drinking under control.
Mental Health help from exercise? (endorphins?). Not a cure but maybe some alleviation for some conditions?
I seem to remember something about GPs being able to prescribe a limited duration course of gym. My local council operates several quite good leisure centres incl. gyms, things like badminton, squash, etc. some with swimming pools. Did that scheme get anywhere? still running?
At the level of what individual practitioners can do for individual patients it's currently called
"social prescribing". The evidence about what works and what doesn't is appearing, and there's some discussion in the archives.
https://www.england.nhs.uk/personalised ... escribing/
But a lot of what is needed isn't currently within the remit of the NHS. It includes explicit assessments of effects on health of
other areas of policy: transport, food, education, employment... just about everything.
Jonathan
I have some experience of social prescribing. At my annual Type 2 Diabetes check, I complained that they were asking me to lose a bit of weight, but not giving me any support in doing so. So I was referred to a social prescriber who sorted out 2 things for me. They put me in contact with a local Diabetes Support Group, which was great but they meet on a Wednesday, which is the same day as my cycling club’s midweek ride, so I hardly go to the support group.
The other thing they did was refer me to a Weight Loss Support Programme called Your Health, Your Way. This is a 12 week programme where you get weighed each week, then you do half an hour of what is essentially circuit training, then have a half hour talk on some aspect of health. This included food labelling, macros, the traffic light system on food labels, safe levels of drinking alcohol, the importance of 5 a day, but not really any specific advice on diet and losing weight. It didn’t really work for me. Over the 12 weeks, I lost about 3kg. I enjoyed the circuit training, but it aggravated my dodgy hip and an old Achilles injury I have. So overall, it didn’t work for me.